Society of Sound file format update

On the 20th of April we implemented our decision to change all future Society of Sound album releases to AIFF file format, replacing the previously supplied FLAC and ALAC.

We decided to change formats because our listening shows that the absolute best sound is gained with no compression at all. We have however listened to your feedback and the next Society of Sound release on the 15th June, and all future albums, will be available in the below file formats:

AIFF 24-bit – Uncompressed audio with no compromise; studio master quality.

FLAC 24-bit – Slight compression makes file smaller yet still high quality.

ALAC 16-bit – Smaller files compatible with portable Apple devices.

 

12 Comments

  • Matthias A says:

    It is a pity to see the move to Apple-centric formats because Apple serves only so small a fraction of the audio world.

    The article above tries to create the false illusion that AIFF 24-bit (“absolute best sound is gained with no compression at all”) were higher sound quality than FLAC 24-bit (“file smaller yet still high quality”).
    This is outrageous. Technically, AIFF and FLAC 24-bit are both lossless formats, true to the bit, there is absolutely zero difference in sound quality, only that AIFF wastes space, which FLAC does not.

    I do not mind that 24-bit audio is presented in two formats, but I do object to changing the 16-bit audio (which suffices for “on the go” music for me) to ALAC only, and ask that you please continue providing FLAC 16-bit.

    The move to AIFF wastes disk and more importantly expensive flash memory space on the mobile devices (be that the USB stick for my car audio, or my Android device), and also wastes download bandwidth because ZIP is not optimized to compress audio signals, so a zip -9 compressed AIFF will be bigger than a lump of flac –best compressed files.

    Personally, I can convert from AIFF or ALAC to FLAC, so for me it is merely an additional step that I did not have to make in the past, but not everyone is as skilled with computers as I am, so the bottom line is that the change to provide 16-bit only in ALAC poses a new problem of accessibility.

    Finally, FLAC is well established with all the lossless-streaming devices across vendors, I therefore strongly propose to continue providing FLAC 16-bit, FLAC 24-bit, which are the formats 90% of the world care about, and B&W feel free to additionally provide formats that are accessible to the Apple users.

    Please keep FLAC both in 24 and 16 bit masterings, and make sure that the 16-bit mastering is not just truncated from 24-bit, but properly re-mastered (at least with proper dithering and resampling before the re-quantization).

    Thank you for your kind consideration of my proposals.

  • Christian says:

    Thank You! With FLAC the SoS will become useful again.

  • James Osborne says:

    Many thanks for taking on board the feedback – much appreciated.

  • Ben says:

    Thanks for making FLAC24 available again, although your description implies it is no longer “Studio Master Quality”. For anyone confused by that, don’t be. FLAC uses lossless file compression (like a ZIP file) rather than lossy audio compression (like MP3). FLAC will sound as good as an AIFF as long as the player has enough processing power to decompress on the fly. If my phone can manage it then I’m pretty sure your audio system can too!
    Sorry to be pedantic, but these things matter.

  • oskar says:

    thank you very much for listening to our feedback!

  • Peter Chapman says:

    Thank you for re-instating FLAC. I am now able to install on my Seagate media server, which does not recognize AIFF as media files.

  • Mario says:

    I too use Apple Lossless and am so glad SoS is making it available once again but I recently downloaded the latest album on AIFF (4608 kpbs) and must say I can truly tell the difference. Both are great options and sound amazing!

  • Stuart Paterson says:

    Thank you for listening to your customers. FLAC 24 forever!

  • pete s. says:

    Thank you for reinstating FLAC!!!!

  • Klaus says:

    Thank you for offering FLAC again.
    This will be (for me) more useful.

  • Federico says:

    Thank you for FLAC!!!

  • InPlainEnglish says:

    Thank you for listening to your customers. I was pleasantly surprised when I saw your email announcing the change in course!

Add a comment

We welcome debate within Society of Sound, but please keep it friendly, respectful and relevant. We have a few house rules which we ask you to abide by to keep the debate intelligent. Read more.
Product enquiry or support issue? Please click here.

Related posts

Acoustic Holography – Dr Gary Geaves (Head of Research & Development)

Acoustic Holography – Dr Gary Geaves (Head of Research & Development)

Recently we’ve been looking into the subject of acoustic holography. With this technique, a set of acoustic measurements made in one … Read more

Bowers & Wilkins Sound Lab thumbnail

Day in the Life of a Development Engineer – David Blakeman

I am one of the newest members of the Bowers and Wilkins R&D Team, and have worked here for two and half years. All the … Read more

Podcast: Is Studio Recording Killing Music?

Sparked on by a love of classic record producers such as Phil Spector, Joe Meek, and Sam Phillips, Bowers & Wilkins got together … Read more